Finding a reliable asphalt roofing contractor in Ottawa Hills is essential for protecting your home against Ohio's challenging weather. At Integrity Home Exteriors, we're confident in our roofing expertise and quality workmanship, but we believe in transparency and helping homeowners make informed decisions. That's why we've evaluated several local companies based on product quality, service standards, customer reviews, and industry certifications.
Understanding Asphalt Roofing Options
3-tab shingles: Economical single-layer option with 25-year to lifetime warranties. Available at Home Depot and Menards.
Architectural shingles: Multi-layered products with enhanced durability and dimensional appearance in various colors and styles. Available from ABC Supply, Roof Ohio, Menards, and Lowe's.
- Premium shingles: Impact-resistant shingles engineered to withstand hail and strong winds with Class 4 impact resistance ratings. Higher-quality options with advanced features and unique aesthetic designs, such as Atlas StormMaster Shake, Pinnacle Impact, Pinnacle Pristine, and Pinnacle Sun shingles.
Leading manufacturers include GAF, Owens Corning, IKO, Atlas, CertainTeed, Malarkey, and TAMKO, offering features like algae resistance and high wind resistance.
How We Evaluated These Companies
Service range: Comprehensive services from installation to repair and maintenance
Customer reviews: Analysis across multiple platforms including Google, BBB, Angi, and others
Warranty options: Both material and workmanship guarantees
Years in business: Track record of reliability in the Ohio area
Product selection: Variety and quality of asphalt shingle options
When looking for a roofing contractor, reviewing both online reviews and checking out warranty details can help you make an informed decision.
Top Asphalt Roofing Companies
Victors Home Solutions
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated contractor based in Aurora serving Northeast Ohio, offering "Service Quality Guarantee" that stands behind all aspects of their work.
Services & Products
Products: Asphalt shingle roofing systems, flat/low slope roofing
Services: Roof repair, replacement, gutters, attic insulation
Service Area: Northeast Ohio with Aurora office
Customer Experience & Warranty
Customer reviews confirm successful repair of issues like improper venting, leaking skylights, damaged shingles, and rotted wood. Their "Service Quality Guarantee" and "Fair Price Guarantee" offer homeowner assurance, though specific warranty duration is not detailed.
Tri-State Windows, Siding & Roofing
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated contractor based in Toledo, serving Northwest Ohio since 1996 (local presence since 2007), licensed in both Ohio and Michigan.
Services & Products
Products: Owens Corning Roofing Systems for asphalt shingles, flat roofing repair
Services: Roof repairs, replacements, windows, siding, gutters
Service Area: Greater Toledo, Northwest Ohio, Southeast Michigan
Customer Experience & Warranty
Their focus on integrated roofing systems suggests repairs involve compatible, recognized materials to maintain system integrity. While specific repair warranty details aren't provided, their Owens Corning Roofing System carries warranty coverage.
Rapid Roof & Remodeling LLC
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated contractor based in Holland, OH, offering comprehensive repair services including leak repair, structural repairs, and storm damage restoration.
Services & Products
Products: Asphalt shingle, metal, flat, and tile roofing materials
Services: Specialized repairs for leaks, storm damage, structural issues
Service Area: Holland, Fulton County, Lucas County, Wood County
Customer Experience & Warranty
Stands out with a specific "5-Year Craftsmanship Warranty" that backs every job, providing clear protection for repair quality. Performs thorough 17-point inspections and potentially uses GAF-certified materials.
Salinas Roofing/Exteriors
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated Toledo-based contractor with impressive credentials: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, CertainTeed ShingleMaster, IKO Craftsman Premier, and Velux Skylight specialist.
Services & Products
Products: Asphalt, metal, flat/rubber, and tile roofing materials
Services: Leak repair, chimney repair, skylight replacement, gutters, siding
Service Area: NW Ohio (Fulton, Lucas, Wood Counties), Monroe County MI, Portage County OH
Customer Experience & Warranty
Their multiple top-tier manufacturer certifications suggest strong commitment to quality materials and workmanship aligned with manufacturer standards. Particularly noteworthy for expertise in less common areas like tile roofing, skylights, and chimney repairs.
Frogtown Roofing Plus
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated contractor with CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster and Owens Corning Certified Contractor credentials, offering thorough pre and post-job inspection processes.
Services & Products
Products: CertainTeed and Owens Corning premium shingles with CertainTeed Integrity Roof System
Services: Roof repair focused on storm/impact damage, attic and ventilation assessment
Service Area: Lucas County, Ottawa County, and Wood County from Maumee/Bowling Green offices
Customer Experience & Warranty
Offers potential access to CertainTeed's Five-Star Warranty (50-year material, 25-year workmanship) though verification for repairs is essential. Features a "Price-Lock Guarantee" to eliminate unexpected costs. Mixed feedback regarding communication and use of subcontractors.
RoofOhio Inc.
Why They Stand Out: A+ BBB rated, EPA Lead-Safe certified contractor based in Swanton, serving Northwest Ohio since 1997 with expertise in metal roofing and storm damage.
Services & Products
Products: Asphalt shingle and metal roofing materials
Services: Storm damage restoration (hail, ice, wind), insurance claim assistance
Service Area: Fulton, Henry, Lucas, Ottawa, and Wood Counties, specifically Swanton, Napoleon, Toledo & Perrysburg
Customer Experience & Warranty
Claims to offer "best no hassle warranties in the industry" though specifics require clarification. Emphasizes using state-of-the-art equipment with thorough job site cleanup ("No nail is left behind") and modern practices.
Salgua Roofing Inc.
Why They Stand Out: Owens Corning Preferred Contractor based in Toledo with over 24 years of specialized experience in unique roof materials.
Services & Products
Products: Asphalt shingles, flat/EPDM, and specialized slate and ceramic tile materials
Services: Specialized repairs for slate roofs, ceramic tile roofs, chimney and pipe flashings, flat/EPDM systems
Service Area: Toledo and surrounding areas
Customer Experience & Warranty
Documented 10-year labor warranty offered in some cases. Overwhelmingly positive reviews across platforms, though one detailed complaint about a complex flat roof project suggests careful vetting for intricate projects. Stands out for explicitly advertised capabilities with specialized materials like slate and tile.
Comparison Table: Top Asphalt Roofing Companies
| Company | Location | Specialties | Damage Types Repaired | Warranty | Key Certifications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Victors Home Solutions | Aurora/NE Ohio | Shingle, Flat/Low Slope | Leaks, Venting, Shingle Damage | Service Quality Guarantee | A+ BBB |
| Tri-State Windows, Siding & Roofing | Toledo | Asphalt Shingle, Flat | General Repairs | OC System Warranty | A+, Owens Corning Certified |
| Rapid Roof & Remodeling LLC | Holland | Shingle, Metal, Flat, Tile | Leaks, Storm, Structural | 5-Year Craftsmanship | A+, Potential GAF Master Elite |
| Salinas Roofing/Exteriors | Toledo | Asphalt, Metal, Flat, Tile, Skylights | Leaks, Chimney | Unspecified | A+, OC Platinum, CT ShingleMaster |
| Frogtown Roofing Plus | Maumee/BG | Asphalt Shingle | Storm/Impact Damage | 25-Yr (Verify for Repairs) | A+, CT Select, OC Certified |
| RoofOhio Inc. | Swanton | Asphalt Shingle, Metal | Storm Damage (Hail, Ice, Wind) | "No Hassle" (Unspecified) | A+, EPA Lead-Safe |
| Salgua Roofing Inc. | Toledo | Slate, Tile, EPDM, Asphalt | Chimney/Flashings, Specialized Materials | 10-Year Labor (Documented) | A+, OC Preferred |
How to Choose the Right Asphalt Roofing Company in Ottawa Hills
1. Verify Credentials and Insurance
Ensure your contractor is properly licensed, insured, and carries workers' compensation coverage.
2. Review Warranty Options
When comparing roofing companies, carefully examine both material and workmanship warranties. Understand what's covered, for how long, and what might void the warranty. The best warranties provide clear coverage for both materials and installation quality, with minimal exclusions or pro-rating. Always read the fine print and ask questions about warranty limitations.
3. Review Multiple Estimates
Get detailed written estimates from at least three companies. Compare not just price, but also materials specified, project timeline, and warranty details.
4. Ask About Installation Practices
Quality installation is just as important as quality materials. Ask about underlayment, ventilation systems, flashing details, and other components that contribute to a complete roofing system.
5. Check References and Reviews
Beyond online reviews, ask for references from recent customers in the Ottawa Hills area with similar roofing projects. Notice the consistency of positive feedback across multiple platforms.
Cost of Asphalt Roofing in Ottawa Hills
Asphalt roofing costs vary based on several factors:
Home size and roof complexity: Larger homes and complex designs require more materials and labor
Shingle quality: Basic 3-tab shingles cost less than premium or impact-resistant options
Existing roof condition: Removal of multiple layers or deck repair adds cost
Additional features: Enhanced ventilation, ice and water shield, or upgraded underlayment
While specific pricing varies by location, asphalt shingle roof replacement generally ranges from $3.50 to $5.50 per square foot for basic materials and installation, with premium options potentially reaching $7.00 or more. For an average 1,500-2,000 square foot home, complete roof replacement typically costs between $15,000 and $35,000.
What are the advantages of asphalt shingles?
Asphalt shingles are cost-effective with good balance between protection, aesthetics, and value. They last for decades, come in various styles and colors, and offer features like algae resistance and wind resistance.
How important are manufacturer certifications?
Certified contractors receive specialized training and can offer enhanced warranties covering both materials and workmanship. These certifications demonstrate commitment to industry best practices.
What features should Ottawa Hills homeowners look for in asphalt shingles?
Consider impact-resistant shingles (Class 4 rating) for hail and wind protection, high wind resistance technologies, and algae resistance features.
What's included in a quality installation?
A professional installation includes property assessment, old material removal, deck inspection, proper underlayment, ice/water shield, quality shingles, ventilation components, and secure flashing. Quality contractors also check attic ventilation.
How long do asphalt roofs last in Ottawa Hills?
Quality architectural shingles typically last 25-30 years, with premium options lasting 30-50 years with proper installation and maintenance. Extreme weather can shorten lifespan, making strong warranties valuable.
Conclusion
Selecting the right asphalt roofing company in Ottawa Hills is crucial for long-term home protection. At Integrity Home Exteriors, we believe quality materials, proper installation, and excellent service create lasting roofs.
Remember that the lowest price rarely equals the best value. We welcome you to compare our certifications, warranties, and customer reviews with the companies above. Contact us today for a free, honest roof assessment.
